Betton Hill Homes for Sale

Betton Hill Homes for Sale

Welcome to Betton Hill, one of Tallahassee's most sought-after neighborhoods, where charm meets convenience in the heart of Florida's capital. Nestled within Leon County, Betton Hill boasts a picturesque setting with tree-lined streets, manicured lawns, and a warm sense of community that makes it an ideal place to call home.

This enchanting subdivision is renowned for its diverse architectural styles, ranging from classic mid-century homes to modern builds, ensuring there’s something to suit every taste. With homes for sale in Betton Hill, prospective buyers will find an array of options, from cozy single-family residences to spacious family estates. Each property reflects the unique character of the neighborhood, often featuring lush gardens, inviting patios, and ample space for outdoor living.

Living in Betton Hill means enjoying the perfect blend of tranquility and accessibility. Residents have easy access to a variety of local amenities, including boutique shops, delightful restaurants, and vibrant parks. Families will appreciate the proximity to top-rated schools and recreational facilities, making it a wonderful place to raise children.

The community spirit in Betton Hill is palpable, with neighborhood events and gatherings that foster connections among residents. Whether you’re looking for a peaceful retreat or a lively community atmosphere, Betton Hill offers the best of both worlds.

Explore the homes for sale in Betton Hill today and discover why this charming subdivision is the perfect place to create lasting memories. Your dream home awaits in this beautiful Tallahassee neighborhood!

Newest Betton Hill Homes for Sale

$525,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 403225 MLS
One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Charm meets modern convenience in this beautifully updated 3 bedroom 2 bath home in the heart of sought-after Betton Hills. Offering 2000 sqft, this inviting home features refinished hardwood floors, a spacious open living and dining area highlighted by a gas fireplace and exposed brick accent wall, and a bright sunroom with brick flooring and a wall of windows overlooking the private backyard. The updated kitchen is designed for everyday living with granite countertops, bar-top seating, a gas range, and black stainless steel appliances. A desirable split-bedroom floor plan provides privacy, while the primary suite offers its own mini-split A/C, walk-in closet, and a spacious bath with a large walk-in shower. Additional features include a versatile flex space perfect for a drop zone, washer and dryer, whole-house generator, workshop/storage shed, carport with storage room, and a generous 0.42 acre lot. Ideally located just minutes from TMH hospital, shopping, dining, and everyday conveniences, this move-in-ready home offers the perfect blend of character, comfort, and thoughtful updates.

2111 Lee Avenue, Tallahassee
$4,750,000
6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 403046 MLS
Tucked behind mature trees on nearly 10 private acres in the heart of Tallahassee lies one of the city's most extraordinary and closely held estates. A true generational opportunity, this remarkable property has been owned by only three families since the early 1940s and represents a level of privacy, acreage, and location that is virtually impossible to replicate. Perfectly positioned just moments from Midtown, Downtown, premier shopping, dining, the area's leading hospitals, and Florida's Capitol, this hidden sanctuary offers an unmatched lifestyle where peaceful estate living and urban convenience exist in perfect harmony. The beautifully appointed residence features six spacious bedrooms, five full bathrooms and half bath, dedicated office space, an inviting sunroom, and thoughtfully designed living areas that seamlessly connect to the surrounding landscape. Every room is designed to embrace natural light and showcase breathtaking views of the property's meticulously maintained grounds. Beyond the home, the estate unfolds into an exceptional outdoor retreat. Enjoy a resort-style swimming pool, your own private putting green complete with fairway, expansive lawns beneath towering canopy oaks, and a detached boat garage with abundant space for recreational vehicles, hobbies, or additional storage. The nearly 10-acre setting offers endless opportunities for entertaining, recreation, and creating memories for generations to come. Properties of this caliber rarely become available. Combining extraordinary acreage, unmatched privacy, timeless character, and one of Tallahassee's most coveted locations, this is more than a home, it is a legacy estate unlike anything else currently offered in Leon County.

1410 Betton Road, Tallahassee
$525,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 402710 MLS
Better than ever and offering exceptional value! This beautifully updated Betton Hills gem features a brand-new HVAC system and is priced below a recent appraisal, giving buyers added confidence and immediate value from day one. Perfectly positioned on one of Betton Hills' most sought-after streets, this inviting 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath home blends timeless character with thoughtful updates and modern comfort. A welcoming front porch invites you inside, where rich hardwood floors, a cozy wood-burning fireplace, and a spacious kitchen create the perfect backdrop for everyday living and effortless entertaining. French doors lead to your own private backyard retreat, complete with lush landscaping, multiple outdoor living spaces, and plenty of room to relax, entertain, garden, or simply unwind. Whether you're hosting friends or enjoying a quiet evening at home, this outdoor oasis is designed to be enjoyed year-round. Need extra space? The detached office/laundry building offers incredible flexibility as a home office, art studio, or creative workspace. A separate storage building and rock driveway with convenient backyard access add even more functionality. Located in the heart of highly desirable Betton Hills, you're just minutes from Midtown, downtown Tallahassee, parks, shopping, restaurants, hospitals, and everything that makes this neighborhood one of the city's most treasured communities. With major system updates already completed, undeniable charm, and a price that stands out in today's market, this move-in-ready Betton Hills home is an opportunity you won't want to miss.

1312 Dillard Street, Tallahassee
$500,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 402655 MLS
BETTON HILLS BEAUTY! Less than a block from Winthrop Park, this thoughtfully expanded and updated 1949 brick home sits on nearly half an acre between Thomasville and Centerville roads. Originally a two-bedroom, one-bath cottage, it has been transformed into a distinctive three- or four-bedroom, two-bath home blending vintage charm with modern function. The kitchen features gold on white GE Café appliances, double ovens and a six-burner cooktop with interchangeable grates. Enjoy a gas fireplace in the formal living room and a wood-burning fireplace with dentil molding in the family room. With a split bedroom floorplan, three bedrooms offer double or walk-in closets, while the primary suite includes a walk-in shower and rose-and-gold ensuite laundry room. Outside features include attractive landscaping, decorative curbing, a new extended driveway, plentiful parking, an extended patio and a spacious yard. Less than a block to Winthrop pickleball, tennis, baseball, playgrounds, and Thomasville Road dining.2 to 3 blocks to TMH, Kate Sullivan, and Cobb Middle. You'll Fall in Love.

1579 Marion Avenue, Tallahassee
$799,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 402412 MLS
One or more photos have been virtually staged. Welcome to 2007 Lee Avenue, a rare opportunity in the heart of Betton Hills. Situated on a double lot spanning approximately 0.76 acres, this 4-bedroom, 3-bath pool home offers 3,036 square feet of living space, a brand-new roof, and one of the most desirable locations in Tallahassee. Inside, you'll find two spacious living areas, an office, original hardwood and parquet flooring, and a flexible floor plan that provides plenty of room for everyday living and entertaining. Large windows throughout the home bring in natural light and showcase views of the beautiful surrounding landscape. The outdoor spaces are equally impressive. A large patio overlooks the pool and backyard, creating the perfect setting for entertaining, relaxing, or enjoying time with family and friends. Mature live oak trees provide shade and character throughout the property, including one of Tallahassee's designated "Patriarch Oaks," a remarkable tree that was already growing when Tallahassee was founded in 1824. The level, elevated lot is a rare find in this area and offers exceptional outdoor space with room to enjoy. Additional features include a two-car garage, oversized driveway, and a circular front drive that provides ample parking for guests. Located just minutes from parks, shopping, restaurants, Whole Foods, the hospitals, and Florida State University, this home combines the charm and space of Betton Hills with the convenience of in-town living. Properties with this combination of lot size, location, character, and outdoor amenities rarely become available.

2007 Lee Avenue, Tallahassee
$489,500
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 402009 MLS
Beautifully classic 3BR/2BA home with a "southern living" feel on one of Tallahassee's most charming streets. Just yards from popular Winthrop Park, you've got fields, playgrounds, baseball diamonds, and tennis courts an easy stroll away. Walkable to Thomasville Rd corridor, putting shopping & dining nearby. Updated home features hardwood floors throughout, an open & updated kitchen, an abundance of natural light, and architectural details to enhance an atmosphere of relaxed elegance. Flexible floor plan with multiple living & dining spaces, including a bright sun room that the owners use as an oversized dining area. Outside you'll enjoy a spacious carport outfitted with generous storage, park-like 0.41 acre fenced lot, large patio, and paved walking paths. Located next door to a dedicated, city-owned green space lot offering extended privacy and pretty views. Already inspected for peace of mind!!

1435 Crestview Avenue, Tallahassee
$1,095,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 401873 MLS
A rare opportunity to own a piece of Tallahassee history. Known as The Clements House, this distinguished Georgian Revival residence was designed by Prentiss Huddleston & Associates and built in 1948. Recognized by the Tallahassee Trust for Historic Preservation, this remarkable home is being offered for only the second time since it was built. Situated on one of only a handful of remaining double lots in Betton Hills, the property offers an exceptional combination of privacy, mature landscaping, and space rarely found in Midtown. The painted white brick exterior enhances the home's timeless architecture while creating elegant curb appeal. Inside, classic character blends seamlessly with thoughtful updates and versatile living spaces. The expansive great room features vaulted ceilings, floor-to-ceiling windows overlooking a beautifully landscaped courtyard, a second kitchen, full bath, private bedroom, and its own exterior entrance—making it ideal for a guest suite, multigenerational living, private office, or separate living quarters. Outdoor living is equally impressive with a patio addition completed in 2019, an encapsulated crawl space for added peace of mind, and a garage and carport offering ample room for vehicles, boats, and additional storage, all thoughtfully positioned out of view from the street. Located in the heart of Betton Hills, you'll enjoy the charm of one of Tallahassee's most sought-after neighborhoods while being just minutes from Midtown's parks, restaurants, shopping, and entertainment. Historic significance, architectural character, and an irreplaceable setting combine to make this a truly exceptional offering.

1545 Lee Avenue, Tallahassee
$447,500
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 401618 MLS
Charming Betton Hills Home! This classic traditional Betton home is surrounded by beautiful mature landscaping on this private and professionally landscaped lot with secret garden path, gazebo and charming brick patio! Spacious floorplan includes a separate living and dining room, eat-in kitchen, cozy den with gas fireplace and huge family room or flex room across the back of the house. Large upstairs primary bedroom with a spacious primary bath and large walk-in attic for extra storage. Two screened in porches, one for relaxing and the other for hobbies, workshop space or other outdoor activities, plus deck. Updates needed, but priced accordingly so upgrades can be made. Located on a quiet dead-in street, close to parks, shopping, hospitals and more! A wonderful place to call home!

2503 Chamberlin Drive, Tallahassee
$450,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 400512 MLS
Classic mid-century charm meets flexible modern living in sought-after Betton Hills! Built in 1959, this spacious 3BR/2BA home offers 1,778 sq. ft. upstairs filled with character, warmth, and natural light. The large living area features beautiful hardwood floors, expansive windows, and a wood-burning fireplace that serves as the focal point of the home, creating the perfect setting for cozy evenings or entertaining guests. The kitchen opens to bright gathering spaces, while the wood-paneled Florida room provides another standout feature of the home, offering the perfect place for morning coffee or evening cocktails while overlooking the peaceful, private backyard. Downstairs, the finished 1,182 sq. ft. basement adds incredible versatility with its own kitchen and bath, ideal for a mother-in-law suite, Airbnb opportunity, home office, guest quarters, or multi-generational living. Outside, the backyard is a gardener’s dream, complete with mature landscaping and a patio overlooking the lush yard, creating a serene outdoor retreat. While the home would benefit from cosmetic updates, it offers great bones, timeless mid-century character, and exceptional potential for a buyer looking to make it their own. Located in one of Tallahassee’s most established and desirable neighborhoods, this Betton Hills property presents a rare opportunity to create your dream home while enjoying flexible living space, abundant natural light, and a private, picturesque setting.

1527 ARGONNE Road, Tallahassee
$365,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 400873 MLS
A Little Love, A Lot of Potential: Future Betton Hills Showpiece in Midtown!! ?? It may be a fixer-upper, but that's where the magic begins! ?? Opportunity is knocking in one of Tallahassee's most sought-after locations. Nestled in the heart of Midtown and within walking distance of the hospital, this property is bursting with potential and ready for someone with vision to bring it back to life. Behind its current cosmetic imperfections lies the foundation of something truly special. With solid bones, a desirable location, and tremendous upside potential, this home presents a rare opportunity to build instant equity while creating the home you've always imagined. A little creativity, a few updates, and some personal touches could transform this property into a stunning Betton Hills gem. Whether you're an investor, renovator, or buyer looking to customize your dream home, you'll appreciate the incredible value and possibilities this property offers. Surrounded by established homes, mature trees, and one of Tallahassee's most desirable neighborhoods, the location alone makes this opportunity worth a closer look. Don't let the current appearance fool you—this diamond in the rough is simply waiting for its next chapter. Bring your imagination, roll up your sleeves, and discover the potential that lies within. The right vision could turn this fixer-upper into one of Betton Hills' true standouts. Roof 2010 HVAC 2016 Opportunity, location, and equity potential—this is the one you've been waiting for.

1463 Marion Avenue, Tallahassee
$425,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 400274 MLS
Charming Betton Hills home in the heart of Midtown Tallahassee! This well-maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath home features hardwood floors, abundant natural light, multiple living spaces, and an updated kitchen perfect for everyday living and entertaining. Step outside to a private backyard retreat with an in-ground pool, and spacious pool deck. Conveniently located near Midtown, Downtown, TMH, shopping, dining, parks, and top schools. A rare opportunity in one of Tallahassee’s most desirable neighborhoods. Come see it for yourself!!!

1485 Spruce Avenue, Tallahassee
$1,075,000
6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 399566 MLS
Just minutes from Midtown, downtown, parks, hospitals, shopping, dining, and the Capitol, this is a rare opportunity to own a home that offers both the charm of an established neighborhood and the comfort of modern updates in one of Tallahassee's premier locations. Thoughtful updates provide peace of mind, including a 2022 roof, 2023 Generac whole-house generator, tankless water heater, and upgraded solar panels. This beautifully maintained home is designed for both everyday living and entertaining, the home features timeless architectural details including extensive crown molding, French doors that fill the rooms with natural light, a graceful domed archway, custom wood cabinetry, and a gas fireplace with a granite surround. With six spacious bedrooms, the flexible floor plan easily adapts to your lifestyle, whether you need home offices, guest suites, hobby rooms, a fitness space, or accommodations for multigenerational living. The primary suite is tucked away as a peaceful retreat with a beautifully renovated bath featuring a soaking tub, oversized walk-in shower, and an impressive walk-in closet. Storage is abundant throughout the home, with generous bedroom closets and a large walk-in pantry. Outside, the backyard becomes an extension of the living space. Mature landscaping, flowering gardens, and fruit trees create a private setting, while the deck, stone patio, and built-in seating invite everything from morning coffee to weekend gatherings with family and friends.

2021 Winthrop Way, Tallahassee
Start Your Search